1719-1729 Rev. James MacGregor
1729-1732 Rev. Matthew Clark
1733-1738 Rev. Thomas Thompson
1739-1791 Rev. William Davison
1791-1795 Supply Pastors
1795-1804 Rev. Jonathan Brown
1804-1810 Supply Pastors
1810-1850 Rev. Edward L. Parker
1851-1856 Dr. Joshua W. Wellman
1857-1859 Rev. Ephraim N. Hidden
1859-1861 14 Supply Pastors
1861-1869 Leonard S. Parker
1871-1873 David Bremner
1875-1877 Edward S. Huntress
1880-1882 Rev. Harris
1883-1884 14 Supply Pastors
1884-1889 Rev. H.M. Penniman
1891-1894 Rev. R. C. Drisko
1895-1897 Rev. J. Lewis Evans
1897-1897 30 Supply Pastors
1897-1903 Rev. R. C. Wilton
1903-1904 Supply Pastors
1904-1924 Rev. F.I. Kelley
1925-1930 Rev. A.V. Woodworth
1931-1934 Rev. Charles T. Hawes
1935-1941 Dr. W. Fred Addison
1941-1947 Rev. John G. Gaskill
1944-1945 Mrs Eleanore C Gaskill
1947-1950 Dr. Charles Milligan
1950-1957 Dr. Robert Henderson
1957-1963 Rev.Thomas DeWolfe
1963-1968 Rev. Herbert Schumm
1968-1968 Rev. William Sipe*
1968-1974 Rev. William E Strait
1974-1975 Rev. Chester Ham*
1975-1988 Rev. Diana J. Augspurger
1988-1988 Rev. John Westhaver*
1988-1989 Rev. Phil Wiehe*
1989-1993 Rev. Nelson (Jim) Howard III
1991-1993 Rev. Susan A Henderson+
1993-1995 Dr. Richard Devor
1995-2010 Rev. Alice M.C. Ling
2003-2009 Rev. Lucy Alexander+
2010-2013 Rev. Sue Remick*
2014-Present Rev. Dr. Deborah Roof
2015-2016 Rev. Heidi Carrington Heath+

* Denotes Interim Pastor
+ Denotes Associate Pastor